Adult Family Care Home vs Assisted Living Facility: Complete Comparison
Understanding the key differences between Adult Family Care Homes and Assisted Living Facilities in Florida to help you make the best care decision for your loved one.
Quick Comparison Overview
| Feature | Adult Family Care Home | Assisted Living Facility |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Residents | Up to 5 residents | 16 or more residents |
| Setting | Residential home | Institutional facility |
| Provider Location | Provider must live on-site | Staff may not live on-site |
| Environment | Family-like, intimate | Larger, more structured |
| Cost | Generally more affordable | Typically higher cost |
| Care Ratio | High staff-to-resident ratio | Lower staff-to-resident ratio |
| Regulatory Agency | Florida AHCA | Florida AHCA |
| Best For | Those seeking personalized, family-like care | Those needing more amenities and activities |
Detailed Comparison
Adult Family Care Home
Maximum Capacity: Up to 5 residents
Adult Family Care Homes are limited to a maximum of 5 residents, creating an intimate, family-like environment. This small group setting allows for highly personalized attention and care.
Assisted Living Facility
Maximum Capacity: 16 or more residents
Assisted Living Facilities typically house 16 or more residents, with some facilities accommodating 100+ residents. This larger setting provides more amenities but less individual attention.
Environment and Setting
Adult Family Care Home
- Residential home setting that feels like a family home
- Intimate, family-like atmosphere
- Less institutional feeling
- Provider lives in the home, creating a true residential experience
Assisted Living Facility
- Purpose-built facility or converted building
- More structured, institutional environment
- More amenities and common areas
- Staff typically do not live on-site
Cost Comparison
Adult Family Care Home
Generally More Affordable
- •Lower overhead costs due to smaller size
- •Often more cost-effective for families
- •Fewer amenities may result in lower monthly costs
- •All-inclusive pricing typically available
Assisted Living Facility
Typically Higher Cost
- •Higher overhead for larger facilities
- •More amenities and services increase costs
- •Base rate plus additional fees for services
- •Wide price range depending on location and amenities
Care and Services
Adult Family Care Home Services
- Personal care assistance with daily living activities
- Medication management
- Meal preparation and nutrition support
- Housekeeping and laundry
- 24/7 on-site provider availability
- High staff-to-resident ratio for personalized care
Assisted Living Facility Services
- Personal care assistance
- Medication management
- Dining services and meal programs
- Housekeeping and maintenance
- More extensive activity programs and amenities
- Lower staff-to-resident ratio
Regulation and Licensing
Both Adult Family Care Homes and Assisted Living Facilities in Florida are licensed and regulated by the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA). However, they operate under different regulations:
Adult Family Care Home
- • Chapter 408, Part II, Florida Statutes
- • Chapter 59A-35, Florida Administrative Code
- • Chapter 429, Part II, Florida Statutes
- • Chapter 59A-37, Florida Administrative Code
Assisted Living Facility
- • Chapter 408, Part II, Florida Statutes
- • Chapter 58A-5, Florida Administrative Code
- • Chapter 429, Part I, Florida Statutes
Which Option is Right For You?
Choose Adult Family Care Home If:
- You prefer a small, intimate, family-like environment
- You want highly personalized attention and care
- Cost is an important consideration
- You value having the provider live on-site
- You want a residential home setting rather than an institutional facility
- You prefer a high staff-to-resident ratio
Choose Assisted Living Facility If:
- You want more extensive amenities and activities
- You prefer a larger community with more social opportunities
- You need specialized programs (memory care, etc.)
- You want on-site medical services or therapy
- You prefer a more structured, institutional environment
- Budget allows for higher monthly costs
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between an Adult Family Care Home and an Assisted Living Facility?
The primary difference is size: Adult Family Care Homes serve up to 5 residents in a residential home setting with the provider living on-site, while Assisted Living Facilities serve 16 or more residents in a larger, more institutional setting. Adult Family Care Homes offer a more intimate, family-like environment with higher staff-to-resident ratios.
Are Adult Family Care Homes less expensive than Assisted Living Facilities?
Generally, yes. Adult Family Care Homes typically have lower overhead costs due to their smaller size, which often results in more affordable monthly rates. However, costs can vary based on location, services provided, and individual facility amenities.
Do both types of facilities provide the same level of care?
Both provide personal care services, medication management, meal preparation, and assistance with daily living activities. However, Adult Family Care Homes often provide more personalized attention due to their smaller size and higher staff-to-resident ratio. Assisted Living Facilities may offer more extensive amenities and specialized programs.
Are both licensed and regulated the same way?
Both are licensed by the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA), but they operate under different regulations. Adult Family Care Homes are regulated under Chapter 59A-35 and 59A-37 of the Florida Administrative Code, while Assisted Living Facilities are regulated under Chapter 58A-5.
Can I visit both types of facilities before making a decision?
Yes, and it's highly recommended. Visiting both types of facilities will help you understand the differences in environment, atmosphere, and care approach. This hands-on experience is invaluable when making such an important decision for yourself or a loved one.
Learn More About Our Adult Family Care Home
Visit our 3530 Datura Street property to see an Adult Family Care Home in action, or learn more about what makes this care option unique.
Additional Resources
Florida AHCA - Adult Family Care Home Information
Official information from the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration about Adult Family Care Homes.
Visit AHCA Website↗Florida AHCA - Assisted Living Facility Information
Official information about Assisted Living Facilities in Florida.
Visit AHCA Website↗Facility/Provider Locator
Search for licensed Adult Family Care Homes and Assisted Living Facilities in Florida.
Search Facilities↗